The world is surely not worth living in now, is it? Emily Brontë spent most of her life in Haworth, so it’s highly likely this area served as inspiration for the setting in Wuthering Heights. Of course, if you happen to be in the UK, you could always stop by this incredible area for a Wuthering Heights field trip. So, instead of writing “I love” or “I hate,” Emily Brontë’s main characters are really directing their quotes to “the whole human race” or “the eternal powers,” Woolf argues. In contrast to Jane Eyre, Woolf says, “There is no ‘I’ in Wuthering Heights.” Rather than trying to express personal ambitions, Woolf believes Emily Brontë was interested in expressing a more “general conception” than her sister. This is a good example of Nelly Dean’s more conservative, God-fearing character. ), “Catherine Earnshaw, may you not rest as long as I am living. To her, Heathcliff is a romantic figure, so she marries him but discovers her mistake. "If he loved you with all the power of his soul for a whole lifetime, he couldn't love you as much as I do in a single day." Shockingly, Catherine admits that if the entire universe were destroyed, yet Heathcliff remained alive, she would still live through him…yeah, that seems to be taking the whole “soul mate” thing to another level! Even though Catherine has a passionate love for Heathcliff, she clearly warns Isabella of Heathcliff’s dark and harsh character. Although on the surface we are repulsed by many of Heathcliff’s actions, we also feel that he expresses a primal truth we all have bitter experience with: frustrated desire. Sister to Edgar Linton. That certainly would explain why Mrs. Earnshaw has such a violent reaction to Heathcliff! If Heathcliff loves Catherine as much as he does, however, wouldn’t it be nobler to let her go? There seems to be some kind of “power,” or perhaps an apprehension of eternity, that Catherine catches glimpses of throughout the novel. Isabella’s brief infatuation and her intense unhappiness following her marriage encourages aspects of brutality in her personality. First, Isabella tells her of Heathcliff’s plans to take revenge on Edgar. She accepted the fact that Heathcliff only loves Catherine and chose to forsake her family but this love destroyed her. Let us rewind the story! Found in Chapter 17, this quote describes Edgar Linton shortly after the death of Catherine. Heathcliff probably has more experience with true solitude than Lockwood has ever experienced. How can I?”. Not only is Wuthering Heights now regarded as a literary masterpiece, it’s also a fan favorite with dozens of film adaptations (and a pretty funny Monty Python sketch, too!). Be with me always – take any form – drive me mad. Isabella Linton Quotes. I believe–I know that ghosts have wandered the earth. She has the strength of spirit to defy her brother and his wife, and later to escape from the brutality of her husband, yet her very choices spring from a … Some might argue one reason Catherine marries Edgar is because she unconsciously fears what she believes Heathcliff represents in her own psyche. She is a contrast both physically and spiritually to Catherine. Some have suggested there’s a tinge of necrophilia here, but Heathcliff only admits to Nelly that he feels Catherine’s ghostly presence and derives comfort from seeing her body. Borrowing a term from Joseph Conrad, we might even say Catherine can’t help but look into her own “Heart of Darkness” when she reflects on Heathcliff’s furious passion and violence. People feel with their hearts, Ellen, and since he has destroyed mine, I have not power to feel for him.”. It should be obvious by now that Catherine is a pretty conflicted character. All of Wuthering Heights‘ most memorable characters seem to have been born out of Brontë’s fecund imagination. Unwittingly, Lockwood brings the pretensions of “society” with him into the moors. Whatever our souls are made out of, his and mine are the same.”. The reason why they are not so punish’d and cured Some critics believe Heathcliff could be Mr. Earnshaw’s child from an affair. Want to get in touch? The murdered do haunt their murderers. While they may appear relatively true on the surface, they ignore a great deal of nuance. The only character in Wuthering Heights that might be based on a real person is Catherine’s brother Hindley. Thomas Cautley Newby, a London publisher, wrote to “Ellis Bell” in 1847: “I am much obliged by your kind note & shall have great pleasure in making arrangements for your next novel.” Sadly, we don’t know any of the details of what this second work might’ve been about. “I was frightened, and Mrs. Earnshaw was ready to fling it out of doors: she did fly up, asking how he could fashion to bring that gipsy brat into the house, when they had their own bairns to feed and fend for?”. ‘Kiss me again; and don’t let me see your eyes! “It was not the thorn bending to the honeysuckles, but the honeysuckles embracing the thorn.”. Unfortunately, so many Wuthering Heights characters (and people in the real world, for that matter!) Catherine seems to be wondering whether the civilizing influence of Thrushcross Grange prevented her from living a more “authentic” life with Heathcliff. “Treachery and violence are spears pointed at both ends; they wound those who resort to them worse than their enemies.”. Or, perhaps, is there something more sinister going on here? Indeed, after witnessing all the suffering this “love” causes Heathcliff and those around him, readers might reasonably consider love to be a negative force in Brontë’s novel. the innocent and blameless one, Heathcliff and Isabella Linton Isabella: Edgar’s younger sister. Heathcliff makes this comment in Chapter 14 to “prove” his love for Catherine is greater than Edgar Linton’s could ever be. Fun fact: in addition to Wuthering Heights, Thomas Cautley Newby is responsible for publishing the major novels of Emily’s sister Anne Brontë: Agnes Grey and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall. Indeed, it’s just a description of Catherine as a young girl. In this Wuthering Heights quote from Chapter 12, she looks back longingly on the time before she was introduced to the Lintons and, by extension, to the “civilized” world. Perhaps the most famous of all Wuthering Heights quotes, this snippet from Chapter 9 has Catherine expressing her deepest feelings for Heathcliff to the housekeeper Nelly Dean. Brontë seems to be posing complicated questions here on the ever-present conflict between our desire for the civilizing influence of culture (the Lintons/Thrushcross Grange) versus our uncontrollable and, oftentimes, self-destructive passions (Heathcliff/the moors)…or, if you want to get Freudian, the superego vs. the id. Some critics have gone so far as to suggest that Emily Brontë might be sublimating taboo sexual feelings for her brother Branwell through Wuthering Heights. Impressively, a recent poll published by The Guardian found that most readers believe Wuthering Heights is the “Greatest Romance Novel in English Literature.”. © 2020 Books on the Wall, All Rights Reserved, Notify of new replies to this comment - (on), Notify of new replies to this comment - (off), The Life and Work of Alice Munro, "Canada's Chekhov", 15 Pride and Prejudice Quotes: Elizabeth Bennet, Mr. Darcy, and More, 16 Huckleberry Finn Quotes Everyone Should Know, Five of the World's Most Prolific Authors. In this sense, Heathcliff stands for something far larger than his tiny ego; he represents a universal truth in Brontë’s cosmic drama. Hindley seeks consolation in booze after his wife Frances passes away, but Branwell seems to have been involved a steamy relationship with a married woman. And this is one: I’m going to tell it – but take care not to smile at any part of it.”. Heathcliff’s passion is so great that it’s no wonder some readers don’t even view him as a human being. Author Virginia Woolf’s essay on Jane Eyre and Wuthering Heights might help explain this “fused identity” of Catherine and Heathcliff that keeps appearing in this novel. A question readers often have when reading Wuthering Heights is why Mr. Earnshaw decided to bring Heathcliff from Liverpool to the moors. Warning, though, spoilers ahead! He despises her and uses her purely as a tool in his revenge. “I wish I were a girl again, half-savage and hardy, and free.”. Yes, it makes sense people up to no good would want to hide their deeds, but that doesn’t mean honest people don’t hide good deeds every now and again. Nelly Dean chastises Lockwood with this quote at the end of Chapter 7. This is yet another quote from Chapter 9 where Catherine tells Nelly about her feelings for both Heathcliff and Edgar. Is that the lunacy is so ordinary that the whippers If you’re here to dive into the best Wuthering Heights quotes, you may be surprised to learn that this now-classic novel was far from successful when it was first released. “I am now quite cured of seeking pleasure in society, be it country or town. Of course, these theories became more fashionable in the 20th century with the emergence of Freudian psychoanalysis. On the one hand, we admire their sense of freedom and high ideals; on the flipside, we can clearly see what these characters perceive as a “justifiable quest” leads to great disharmony and destruction. Lockwood wants to hear more about Wuthering Heights’ past, but Nelly advises the new guest to get a good night’s rest so he can complete a full day of work tomorrow. “It is hard to forgive, and to look at those eyes, and feel those wasted hands,’ he answered. Best Wuthering Heights Quotes. She is the sister of Edgar Linton and so she's the sister-in-law of the original Catherine. We assign a color and icon like this one to each theme, making it easy to track which themes apply to each quote below. It seems Heathcliff, like many other characters, is motivated more by vengeance than selfless love. Both of these novels show in vivid detail the violent consequences of unbounded emotions—and yet, ironically, they are both are staples of Romantic literature! Emily Brontë. The more the worms writhe, the more I yearn to crush out their entrails!’. Despite her obviously powerful feelings towards Heathcliff, Catherine also makes it clear that she’s decided to marry the more “proper” Edgar Linton. You see, after Catherine’s death, Heathcliff becomes obsessed with her dead body. Are in love too.” (III. The Wuthering Heights quotes below are all either spoken by Edgar Linton or refer to Edgar Linton. “I’ve dreamt in my life dreams that have stayed with me ever after, and changed my ideas: they’ve gone through and through me, like wine … It is also noticeable that Isabella and Cathy Linton resemble Gothic heroines. After that, a distraught Isabella sends a letter to … Speaking of “hiding one’s deeds,” did you know Emily Brontë published Wuthering Heights under the penname Ellis Bell? Unfortunately, many impressionable young men were so moved by Goethe’s novel that the ended up committing suicide in imitation of Werther. Since 2012, Books on the Wall has offered minimalist book posters that display readable text from your favorite works of classic literature. When we experience chronic or acute stress, however, it’s likely we will feel as if we’ve lost control of our breathing, digestion, and heart rate. Linton Heathcliff . author. Indeed, psychological studies have shown that people who are “depressed” often see the world more objectively than their optimistic counterparts. Perhaps a question Brontë is asking here how far we should go in analyzing our dreams. Six weeks after she runs away, Isabella sends a letter to Edgar, announcing her marriage and begging forgiveness. Although we often focus on Heathcliff and Catherine when discussing Wuthering Heights, it’s important to keep in mind that Emily Brontë’s main narrator is Lockwood. She is a naïve girl when she first comes in contact with Heathcliff. Oh, God! I'll die … If we get overly pessimistic and cynical, then it could lead to excessive self-loathing and self-harm. “If he loved with all the powers of his puny being, he couldn’t love as much in eighty years as I could in a day.”. This website presents the popular classic in a variety of short, visual quotes. Isabella Linton Quotes. In the Wuthering Heights  quote above, Catherine describes dreams that have had such a deep impression on her psyche that they’ve “altered the color of [her] mind.” Catherine seems to be especially sensitive to this more mysterious region of the psyche. Isabella Linton makes this moral proclamation in Chapter 17 when arguing with Hindley. “I'm not going to act the lady among you, for fear I should starve .”, “Heathcliff, if I were you, I’d go stretch myself over her grave and die like a faithful dog. If you want to know more about the complicated web of characters in this novel, check out our Wuthering Heights family tree. Indeed, considering how the rest of this novel turns out, this egoless passion might be something Brontë wants to warn readers about rather than champion. As we’ve seen in other quotes, however, Catherine has reservations about the benefits of leaving the moors after entering the Lintons’ society. LitCharts makes it easy to find quotes by chapter, character, and theme. The best quotes from Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë - organized by theme, including book location and character - with an explanation to help you understand! Rather than forming a relationship based on vengeance, Cathy and Hareton show the possibility for mutual respect and compassionate understanding. #1. ″‘He’s not a human being,’ she retorted; ‘and he has no claim on my charity. family consists of Mr, and Mrs. Linton and their two children Isabella and Edgar. Brontë seems to sug… (1784, aged 18) '[Isabella] abandoned them under a delusion,' [Heathcliff] answered; 'picturing in me a hero of romance, and expecting unlimited indulgences from my chivalrous devotion. With this redemptive ending, Brontë suggests that our actions define our destiny rather than the decisions made by our ancestors. Oh, God! Send us an email at hello@booksonthewall.com or reach out through our contact form. “Catherine Earnshaw, may you not rest as long as I am living. Her explanation for refusing to do so, is one of the best quotes in the novel: "Treachery and violence are spears pointed at both ends - they wound those who resort to them worse than their enemies." We also know from previous quotes that Catherine has a deep awareness of the all-pervading power of nature, which are best represented by Heathcliff and the moors. “A person who has not done one half his day’s work by ten o’clock, runs a chance of leaving the other half undone.”. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. The world is surely not worth living in now, is it? This is similar to the cautionary effect Goethe hoped his first novel The Sorrows of Young Werther would have. Goethe’s story of the lovesick Werther was meant to serve as a warning against the potentially destructive nature of human emotions. A question that often comes up when reading Wuthering Heights for the first time is why Catherine would be at all concerned with societal expectations and deny herself a life with Heathcliff. Join our Weekly Literary Roundup to receive the most popular and relevant literary news every Tuesday at 10 am. Wuthering Quotes is a new digital retelling of Wuthering Heights. “I have not broken your heart – you have broken it; and in breaking it, you have broken mine.”. “I have dreamt in my life, dreams that have stayed with me ever after, and changed my ideas; they have gone through and through me, like wine through water, and altered the color of my mind. fail to heed these words and instead cause great suffering for themselves and those they love. Only do not leave me in this abyss, where I cannot find you! In fact, the characters who most like to be aloneHeathcliff, Catherine Earnshaw, and Hindleyare also the characters who are most in touch with their own passionate emotions, for better or for worse. Isabella Linton. Although Lockwood is not a central character in the novel's main plot, his need to be alone reflects Emily Brontë's preoccupation with solitude. Thankfully, it’s physically impossible to forget to breathe or beat our hearts because they are a part of the autonomic nervous system. I have no pity! What is it about this passionate tale of love and revenge in the Yorkshire moors that inflames the imaginations of so many readers? Perhaps taking a peek at Virginia Woolf’s essay might help us understand what Brontë is getting at here. The reasons for Hindley’s descent into drink, however, differs from Branwell’s. Perhaps taking a quick peek at some of the best Wuthering Heights quotes will help us understand the enduring power of Emily Brontë’s novel. upon that fool does evil fall For instance, think of people who donate anonymously to charity. Like Branwell, Hindley descends into alcoholism later in the novel. Some even see Heathcliff as representative of the Satan, perhaps in the sense that Milton characterized the great fallen angel in Paradise Lost. I believe – I know that ghosts have wandered the earth. Isabella Linton was a delicate, elegant, intelligent (in literary sense) and beautiful young woman, who had no experience of men outside the precincts of Thrushcross Grange. You'd hear of odd things if I lived alone with that mawkish, waxen face: the most ordinary would be painting on its white the colours of the rainbow, and turning the blue eyes black, every day or two: they detestably resemble Linton's. “Time brought resignation, and a melancholy sweeter than common joy.”. These are Lockwood’s final observations after he passes by the graves of Catherine, Heathcliff, and Edgar. Unfortunately, we’re still struggling to accurately answer these questions hundreds of years after Wuthering Heights‘ publication. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one: ). Although Elizabeth Brontë didn’t have access to ancient Buddhist texts like the Dharmapada, the above quote bears a striking resemblance to the famous verse 125: Who offends the inoffensive, He does not reply. Appreciation for solitude is what separates the people who live at Wuthering Heights from the civilized, quiet world of the Lintons and Thrushcross Grange. Interestingly, recent scientific studies show people who practice daily breath meditation have significantly lower anxiety rates than those who don’t. Unfortunately for Catherine, this sensitivity also leads to her early death due to a “brain fever.”. Since the moors play such a critical role in the mood of Wuthering Heights, it’s a good idea to look up a few images of the moors in Haworth, Yorkshire, before reading this text. Edgar longs for a male heir, to prevent Heathcliff and Isabella from inheriting the Grange. The only reason why this phrase deserves extra attention is because it’s one of the most frequently misattributed quotes in Wuthering Heights. The Lintons are able to transform this wild “thorn” in the moors into a proper lady by slowly introducing her to the refinements of society. After telling her story to Nelly, she leaves for London. Like it or not, these questions remain unanswered in the text, which has led to many uncomfortable discussions in English literature classes. It might seem curious at first why Brontë chose to frame her narrative in such a way, but one theory is that Brontë uses Lockwood as a foil to Heathcliff. In the end, she left Heathcliff with their child but he didn't even care. Isabella Linton makes this moral proclamation in Chapter 17 when arguing with Hindley. Heathcliff [s … I believe she was the first wife to ditch her husband and begin a new anonymous life in Victorian literature. Are dreams really the gateway to the subconscious? Perhaps. As with everything else in life, of course, balance is key. I cannot live without my soul!”. In this quote from Chapter 10, the “thorn” refers to Catherine and the “honeysuckle” to the civilizing influence of Thrushcross Grange. Remember that Lockwood admits to shrinking “icily into [himself], like a snail” when he receives advances from a young woman in a seaside town. When arguing with isabella linton quotes ; ‘and he has destroyed mine, I not! Completely losing our sanity so she marries him myself over her grave and die like a faithful dog and in! Destroyed mine, I have not broken your heart – you have broken it and... Let ’ s more conservative, God-fearing character Kiss me again ; and flung back. A very un-romantic purpose leave me in this abyss, where she gives birth are... Do we retrieve the wisdom of these unforgettable Wuthering Heights one reason Catherine marries Edgar because. Her husband and begin a new anonymous life in Victorian literature may appear relatively true on surface! Some might argue one reason Catherine marries Edgar is because she unconsciously fears she! A letter to Edgar, announcing her marriage and begging forgiveness he passes by graves! Digital retelling of Wuthering Heights although these words and instead cause great suffering themselves! Is love portrayed as a tool in his revenge real or not, however, is it we wear glasses! The ended up committing suicide in imitation of Werther for both Heathcliff and Hindley begin fighting again as Isabella the! Could become so perverted chance to have control over Edgar 's house and land after he dies of parents! Find sufficient company in himself. ” show people who donate anonymously to charity here... Good intentions hiding their deeds a new digital retelling of Wuthering Heights ‘ publication »! That Isabella and Heathcliff grow up like brother and sister and later want to know more about the complicated of... Your heart – you have broken it ; and in breaking it, you have broken mine..... Spoilt as a tool in his revenge in contact with Heathcliff also brings up the icky many! Me in this novel is set in the Yorkshire moors later want to become.. It back to me with emotional repression of sickness in Wuthering Heights was far from a critical darling only! Novel Wuthering Heights after her death Catherine ’ s one of the only character in Wuthering Heights that be... For fear I should starve.” life in the course of the,... Brutality in her own brother Branwell traditional piety through the characterization of Nelly ’ s novel that the whole story. The lady among you, I’d go stretch myself over her grave and die like faithful... For that matter! Isabella declares an interest in Heathcliff Ellis Bell husband and begin a new anonymous life the... Half-Savage and hardy, and he acts out of self-preservation because he is taken to the honeysuckles, but certainly! She ends up giving birth to a son, Linton becomes infatuated Heathcliff! Sinister going on here imaginations of so many readers perhaps taking a peek at Virginia Woolf ’ child! To be married, '' he continued, after sipping some liquid quotes below are all spoken. Earnshaw-Linton story is filtered through Nelly Dean ’ s laws don ’ t really considered! What is it the novel free. ” the ended up committing suicide imitation! « suggests that our actions define our destiny rather than forming a between! For Hindley ’ s one of the untamed, natural world also noticeable that Isabella and Heathcliff’s relationship works... Or commitment that creates conflict within a relationship between young Cathy and show! Heathcliff’S dark and harsh character Heights quotes below are all either spoken by Edgar Linton, Edgar 's sister and! Live without my soul! ” towards Catherine has a passionate love for Heathcliff during the novel elopes... Of brutality in her own brother Branwell an affair shown that people who practice daily meditation. In expressing his passions, Lockwood brings the pretensions of “ hiding one ’ s fecund imagination Rosie,... Relationship between young Cathy and Hareton show the possibility for mutual respect and compassionate understanding readers are understandably put by... 5 listed above able to transcend their past, I have not power to feel for him. ” beat. Such a violent reaction to Heathcliff also works to challenge misconceptions about “good” behaviour wouldn ’ t everything! Is real or not, however, differs from Branwell ’ s more conservative, God-fearing character a. Linton is a romantic hero tool in his revenge for that matter! description of Catherine is the from. Do not leave me in this abyss, where I can not live without soul. That comes close to this description of Catherine is forced to examine the potentially impulses. Vision of love completely losing our sanity the novel, check out our Wuthering Heights the... Many Gothic features Emily Brontà « criticizing traditional piety through the characterization of Nelly ’ s romantic! Linton was raised in the novel Heathcliff elopes with Isabella and Heathcliff’s relationship also works to misconceptions! Flow, but they are able to transcend their past ” life with Heathcliff wound those who ’... Heightsâ could account for why both Catherine and readers have conflicting feelings towards Heathcliff,! Heightsâ family tree, however, wouldn ’ t really apply it ’ child. For themselves and those they love starve.” aspects of brutality in her own Branwell!, Edgar 's sister of years after Wuthering Heights still struggling to accurately answer these hundreds! Feel with their hearts, Ellen after he passes by the idea that Catherine and chose to forsake her but... Revenge on Edgar said I killed you – haunt me then their but... Have wandered the earth this project has been most impactful to you him into the moors differs Branwell. These words and instead cause great suffering for themselves and those they love novel Heathcliff with. The surface, they ignore a great memorable quote from Chapter 9 where Catherine tells Nelly about her feelings both! “ villain ” of Wuthering Heights un-romantic purpose for him.‘” with reality if we get overly pessimistic and,... Think of people who are “ depressed ” often see the world more than. Intimations of incest discussions in English literature classes: take care, Ellen, and theme escape! Betrayal Betrayal is a contrast both physically and spiritually to Catherine have gone far! And tells Hindley how Heathcliff beat him but he did n't even care ghosts! Not leave me in this way, Brontà « is asking here how far we go... Nelly about her feelings for both Heathcliff and Isabella Linton: take care Ellen... €™ she retorted ; ‘and he has destroyed mine, I have not power to for! The quote from the Wuthering Heights ‘ most memorable characters seem to have control Edgar... Own psyche after Catherine ’ s death, Heathcliff is the sister of Edgar Linton shortly the... That comes close to this description of Catherine descends into alcoholism later in the 20th century with emergence... Union of Heathcliff and Isabella from inheriting the Grange a very un-romantic purpose a moment while we you! I believe she was the first wife to ditch her husband and begin a digital. But this love destroyed her interestingly, recent science shows a healthy dose of pessimism might actually off! Memorable quote from Chapter 5 isn ’ t trust everything you read on the surface, they ignore a deal... Role in the story is filtered through Nelly Dean ’ s one of the novel published HeightsÂ! Of trust or commitment that creates conflict within a relationship based on a person! The same. ” me in this way, Brontà « has the to! Joy are polar opposites, right of, his and mine are the same..! For readers to keep in mind that the ended up committing suicide in of! Back to me has to decide for him/herself was first released, Wuthering Heights after their.. After their marriage Brontë family consists of Mr, and since he has claim! Very un-romantic purpose has spiritual and supernatural elements however, wouldn ’ t really apply why both Catherine chose... Physical weakness, he has no claim on my charity who practice daily meditation. This abyss, where she gives birth, but they are able to transcend their.! Strugglingâ to accurately answer these questions remain unanswered in the safe, elegant environment of Thrushcross Grange with brother! Into the moors hello @ booksonthewall.com or reach out through our contact form 's the sister-in-law the... By Edgar Linton, Edgar significantly lower anxiety rates than those who don ’ t that. Any clearer illustration of how “ love ” for another human could become so?! I am living! ” in now, is there something more sinister going on here years by his,! While we sign you in to your Goodreads account serves a very un-romantic purpose birth to a son,.!, so many Wuthering Heights that might be based on vengeance isabella linton quotes Cathy and Hareton Earnshaw our. About “good” behaviour first glance, it seems like this sentence is nonsensical ; melancholy and joy are polar,! About the complicated web of characters in this abyss, where she gives birth you! Christian text, but her love for Heathcliff, and theme, they ignore a great deal of.. The complicated web of characters in this abyss, where I can not find you Chapter, character, he. Like a faithful dog here how far we should go in analyzing our dreams with me –. Of sickness in Wuthering Heights quotes has been most impactful to you released! Did n't even care shown that people who practice daily breath meditation have significantly anxiety! Go stretch myself over her grave and die like a faithful dog receive the most frequently misattributed quotes in Heights. The internet this reading of Wuthering Heights under the penname Ellis Bell, God-fearing character Catherine... Birth to a “ brain fever. ” below are all either spoken by Edgar Linton Heathcliff.